Heineman Winery produces 25 varieties of wine, as well as two non-alcoholic grape juices. And while Heineman Winery does ship their wine, they can only do so inside of Ohio. So, if you are joining us from out of state, you’ll need to get your fill in person at the Heineman Winery Gift Shop.

Heineman Winery makes and bottles all of their wines on site, from grapes grown on the island. A glass of wine from the winery is a uniquely Put-in-Bay experience. If you are unsure which of their many varieties you’d like to take home with you, take part in a wine tasting in their wine garden.

Heineman sells their wines by the bottle or by the case. They have the popular varieties like Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon, as well as more unusual varieties, like Gewurtzraminer and Traminette. You can check out a complete list before coming at their online store here.

Crystal Cave

If you don’t drink wine, there’s still a great reason to stop by. Also on site is the remarkable Crystal Cave. Tours of this amazing Put-in-Bay landmark helped the winery survive prohibition, when so many other Put-in-Bay wineries were forced to close their doors. There were 17 wineries on South Bass Island before prohibition, and Heineman Winery is the only one to survive it. That makes Crystal Cave a natural wonder worth checking out.

You can then enjoy a glass of Heineman Winery’s grape juice. They make a grape juice from both varieties of grapes they grow, Concord and Catawba, and these are also available for purchase in the gift shop, as well as the online store. Note that while Heineman Winery can only ship their wines inside of Ohio, they can ship their grape juice anywhere in the world! So don’t worry when you run out of what you took home!


978 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, USA