Everyone loves Subway. On Put-in-Bay, they make it even easier to devour their freshly made sandwiches. From late-night snacking to sustenance on the boat, eat fresh at Subway any time.

Located in the lobby of the Commodore Resort and right next door to Mr. Ed’s, the delicious aroma of freshly baked bread beckons to customers. With the perfect mix of selection and value, Subway is a favorite among Put-in-Bay visitors.

Signature sandwiches, like the Meatball Sub, pack a powerful flavor punch. Breakfast is served daily and there’s always a value menu available. They also provide a range of healthy options like the light and tasty Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki. Subway salads are just as good as their subs! Go the personalized route, creating your own sub with a large selection of fresh veggies, deli meats, and sauces.

Subway Catering

Put-in-Bay’s Subway also provides catering for a whole host of events. For large groups, they make it a breeze with their party sub, sandwich platters, desserts, and drinks. Try out a boxed lunch the next time you head out on a fishing charter. The perfect treat to enjoy after landing that trophy walleye on Lake Erie!

Late Night and Pool Bar Eats

We all know Put-in-Bay visitors love the nightlife. This location is open late to make sure you always have something good to eat while dancing at The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s or partying at one of the many downtown bars. The MIST Pool Bar is just a few steps away so when your sub craving hits, Subway is there to satisfy.

The Put-in-Bay location has recently become one of the most popular locations in the entire region. Their healthy, filling sandwiches and extended hours are perfect for island life. Eat fresh and enjoy your summers on Put-in-Bay!