Mama Maria’s Pizza serves exactly what hungry Put-in-Bay visitors are looking for after a day on the boat or a night bar hopping. Open late, people flock here for eats after midnight.

Mama Maria’s Offering

Delicious pizza served piping hot is topped with lots of fresh ingredients, fun toppings, and plenty of cheese and sauce. The meatball subs are massive. With succulent all-beef meatballs served on a fresh roll with so much cheese, you can barely see the meatball underneath. Tasty wraps round out the menu.

Location Location Location

Mama Maria’s is right on Delaware Avenue, the heart of Put-in-Bay. With a patio perfect for people watching, take load off and take in the soul of the island. This pizza joint is very close to the Jet Express terminal so if you find yourself craving pizza on the way over to the island, a gooey slice is right around the corner.

Other Put-in-Bay offers on Delaware Avenue include Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille, Frosty’s Bar, Village Bakery and Cafe, and The Round House. There is always plenty to eat and drink on Delaware Avenue. Live music spills out onto the streets during the hot summer nights. Stroll up and down the block. You’re sure to see plenty of people you know, and even make some new friends!

Summer’s on Put-in-Bay are warm and welcoming. Mama Maria’s is one of the many exceptional dining options to chose from. Everyone loves pizza and Mama Maria’s delivers pies for everyone’s taste buds


266 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, USA