A Put-in-Bay staple for over 60 years, Frosty Bar serves everyone from boaters to day trippers, vacationers, and Island natives. Everyone loves Frosty Bar. With ice cold beers served in their signature frosty mugs to an extensive menu, this place can’t be beat. Live entertainment, competitive, yet friendly, games of pool, and sports on the TV, there’s always something fun going on.
Along with Big Man’s Burrito Stand at the rear of the property, Frosty’s menu packs a serious flavor punch. Known for their piping hot pizza, they also serve up overflowing subs full of fresh ingredients, salads, and fountain drinks.
Frosty Bar Menu Highlights
- Country Benedict
- Buttermilk and Whole Grain Pancakes
- Breakfast Cocktails
- Buffalo Ranch Pizza
- Triple Pepperoni Pizza
Start your vacation bright and early at Frosty’s with their amazing breakfast menu. With homemade pancakes, breakfast sandwiches, and weekly specials, each menu item pairs wonderfully with a brunch cocktail. The best Bloody Mary in Ohio can be found at Frosty, topped off with a signature Frosty pickle.
Frosty Bar Specialty Breakfast Cocktails
- Spicy Peppercorn Bloody Mary
- Garlic Herb Bloody Mary
- Cuban Orange Juice
- Cafe Cooler (Smirnoff Vanilla vodka, Irish Cream liqueur and coffee over ice)
- Tropical Mimosa
- Beer-mosa (Shock Top Belgian White Ale and orange juice)
Frosty’s also supports many local breweries. This includes Great Lakes, Rhinegeist, Fat Heads, Market Garden, Platform, and Brew Kettle.
Located right in the middle of downtown Put-in-Bay and steps away from the Jet Express Ferry terminal, visitors can stop of at Frosty Bar before heading off to see the islands attractions.
It’s easy to spend the whole day at Frosty. Relax in the comfy, cool backyard bar after a morning on the boat and stick around for DJ’s who spin dance music on the weekends. Eat, drink, and be merry at Frosty Bar!
Frosty Bar Hours
Frosty’s is open seven days a week.
11 AM-7 PM Monday-Thursday
11 AM-1 AM Friday
7 AM-1 AM Saturday
7 AM-7 PM Sunday
Come in from 7 AM-11 AM Saturday or Sunday for Frosty Bar breakfast. You’ll be very glad you did!
John N: “We love visiting the Island in the Fall. Our first stop is always Frosty’s for an ice cold beer and watching ESPN game day previews for the big college football games of the day! It’s a tradition in the Fall! Later in the evening we return for a Frosty Pizza. They are our favorites along with an ice cold Great Lakes Dortmunder Gold!!! Now that’s a great Saturday on Put-in-Bay! Friendly servers and a great selection of draft beers! Great pizza and ice cold beer, doesn’t get much better than that!”
Sam T: “We stopped in on our trip for lunch! We had heard it was a great pizza place and I’ve tried a good number of pizza places! We got there 12 inch pie with bacon and pepperoni on it with a side of bread sticks. The cheese was amazing on the pizza complimented by the smokey bacon was heavenly!! We didn’t know if it was enough for us we like to eat. We split the bread sticks two each and 2 slices of pizza each and we were full. Had to get a box to take the rest with us! Price was decent for Put in Bay. I figured it was about 32 dollars for pizza,bread sticks and two pops!”
Derek B: “This restaurant-bar has inside seating but as the day was wonderful and sunny we sat out back at the Taco Bar. Menu was southern focused and featured the Taco Bar as well as individual order items. I had their Taco salad and quite enjoyed it, and my partner had gyros on flatbread and also enjoyed that. Prices are average, and their drink list had some fun concoctions on it, as well as wine, local beers etc. Staff was very friendly and wait times were short.”